Peacekeeping guide
Thanksgiving conversation starters for every age at the table
Questions that get Grandpa, the teenagers and the five-year-old talking to each other.
- ByTelemarketers Save Thanksgiving Team
- Served
- Reading time3 min
Short answer
The best Thanksgiving conversation starters are open, light questions that anyone can answer from their own life, such as "What's a family recipe we should never lose?" or "What did you want to be when you were ten?" Ask them to the whole table, let the youngest or oldest answer first, and follow up on the answers instead of moving straight to the next question.
Key takeaways
- Open questions about memories, food, travel and "would you rather" choices work for every age.
- Questions that cross generations, like asking grandparents about their first job, get the most stories.
- Let kids answer first; adults relax when the first answer is silly.
- Skip anything that asks people to judge or rank each other, which is where friendly turns tense.
Thanksgiving puts a dozen people of every age around one table and expects them to talk for two hours. Some years that just happens. Other years you get the weather, the traffic, and then a long silence broken by someone bringing up the one topic everyone dreads. A few good questions in your pocket fix most of that. Here are starters sorted by who you're talking to, and some tips for asking them well.
What makes a good Thanksgiving conversation starter?
A good starter is open, light, and answerable by anyone from their own life, with no right answer and nothing to argue about.
Compare "Did you have a good year?" with "What's the best thing you ate this year?" The first gets "Yeah, fine." The second gets a story, then three other people chiming in with theirs. Good starters share a few traits:
- They're open, so they can't be answered with yes or no.
- They're about the person's own experience, so nobody can be wrong.
- They're easy for a seven-year-old and a seventy-year-old alike.
- They don't ask anyone to judge another person, a group, or a belief.
Our conversation card deck is built on exactly these rules, if you'd rather deal than memorize.
Which questions work for kids?
Kids answer best when the question is concrete, a bit silly, and lets them be creative.
- "If our dog could talk, what would he complain about first?"
- "If you could invent a new Thanksgiving food, what would be in it?"
- "Which superpower would be most useful at this dinner?"
- "What's the funniest thing that happened at school this year?"
- "If you were the parent for a day, what would the rules be?"
Ask the kids first. Their answers are usually funny, and that sets an easy tone for the adults.
Which questions get teenagers talking?
Teens open up when the question treats them as the expert and doesn't feel like an interview.
- "What show should everyone here be watching right now?"
- "What's a song from this year that the adults would actually like?"
- "If you could live in any city for a year, where would it be?"
- "What's something you can do that nobody at this table knows about?"
- "Which video game world would be the best to live in?"
Skip grades, college plans and dating. They get those questions all season long.
Which questions work for grandparents and older relatives?
Ask older relatives about specific memories, such as first jobs, first homes and old family traditions, because those questions bring out stories nobody has heard.
- "What was your first job, and what did it pay?"
- "What did Thanksgiving look like when you were a kid?"
- "What's a family recipe that should be written down before it's lost?"
- "How did you two meet?" (A classic for a reason.)
- "What's the best piece of advice you were ever given?"
These questions also let younger people learn family history without it feeling like homework. Someone may want to write a few of the answers down.
What are good questions for the whole table?
Whole-table questions work best when they're quick to answer and invite a friendly debate about something harmless.
| Question | Why it works |
|---|---|
| "Rank the pies: pumpkin, pecan, apple. No ties." | Everyone has an opinion, nothing is at stake |
| "Window seat or aisle seat?" | Fast, funny, and reveals personalities |
| "What's one thing you're looking forward to next year?" | Hopeful, and everyone can answer |
| "What's the best trip you've ever taken?" | Gets travel stories going |
| "Would you rather host every holiday forever or never again?" | Gets a laugh from whoever is hosting |
Harmless debates are useful. They let people enjoy disagreeing without anyone getting hurt, which is a good outlet for the relatives who like to argue.
How do you ask so the conversation keeps going?
Ask one question to the whole table, follow up on the answers, and let the conversation wander before you ask the next one.
- Ask during a natural pause, such as when plates are being passed.
- Answer first yourself if people hesitate. A short, slightly embarrassing answer works wonders.
- Follow up: "Wait, what happened after you missed the flight?"
- Bring quieter people in by name: "Grandma, did you ever take a trip like that?"
- Let the talk drift. If a topic catches, you don't need the next card yet.
Which topics should you leave off the list?
Leave out questions that ask people to defend opinions, compare family members, or talk about money, weight or relationships.
These are the questions that turn a light dinner tense. If someone else brings one up, a quick redirect helps; our guide to steering a family dinner away from an argument has a few ways to do it. And if all else fails, there's always the pie ranking.
Seconds, anyone? A few questions
- How many conversation starters should I prepare?
- Five or six is plenty for a meal. A good question can carry fifteen minutes of stories, and the conversation usually finds its own way after that. Keep a few spares for the lull after the main course.
- What if my teenager won't join in?
- Ask questions where they are the expert, such as the best show right now, a game, music or something they made. Avoid putting them on the spot about grades or plans, and let them answer in one word if they want.
- Should conversation starters be written on cards?
- Cards help, especially with kids, because they make it a game and take the pressure off the host. Our home page has a free deck of conversation cards you can deal from a phone at the table.